Table Of Contents
Smith Vantage MIPS Review: Best Ski & Snowboarding Helmets
- Comfort 90%
- Warmth 90%
- Ventilation 90%
- Safety Tech & Features 90%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 60%
Weight: 501.8 grams
Adjustment System: BOA FS360 Fit System
Number of Vents: 18
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Goggle Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: Yes
Price: $156-$260
What We Like: Most of the Features of the Quantum at a Lower Price
What We Don’t: Lacks the Ultra-Premium Protection of the Quantum
The Smith Vantage MIPS is right on par with the Smith Quantum MIPS as a top pick for the best ski and snowboard helmet on the market. With an MSRP of $260, it is still expensive, and we are not sure that the slight price difference sets it apart enough from the Quantum to make us choose the Vantage over it. However, there are a couple of areas where the Vantage actually outshines the Quantum, making it a potentially better buy for some riders.
Compare to Similar Products
- Comfort 100%
- Warmth 100%
- Ventilation 80%
- Safety Tech & Features 100%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 40%
Pros
Class-Leading Safety
Top All-Around Performance
Cons
Heavy
Expensive
Weight: 623.69 grams
Adjustment System: BOA FS360 Fit System
Number of Vents: 22
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Google Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: Yes
Giro Range MIPS
- Comfort 90%
- Warmth 100%
- Ventilation 80%
- Safety Tech & Features 90%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 60%
Pros
Unparalleled Fit Adjustment
Goggle Compatibility
Cons
Expensive
Can Cause Ear Pain for Some Riders
Weight: 538.65 grams
Adjustment System: ConformFit technology
Number of Vents: 12 adjustable
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Goggle Attachment: Yes
Visor: Yes
Audio Compatibility: Yes
Giro Nine MIPS
- Comfort 70%
- Warmth 80%
- Ventilation 70%
- Safety Tech & Features 70%
- Goggle Compatibility 70%
- Weight 70%
Pros
Mips Tech
Warm
Light
Comfortable
Great Price to Performance Ratio
Cons
Non-Removable Earpads
Lower Tier In Form Fit System
Weight: 436 grams
Adjustment System: In-Form Fit System
Number of Vents: 14
Removable Ear Covers: No
Google Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: No
Salomon MTN Lab Review
- Comfort 70%
- Warmth 50%
- Ventilation 100%
- Safety Tech & Features 80%
- Goggle Compatibility 70%
- Weight 100%
Pros
A True Ski Mountaineering Helmet
Ultralight
Well Ventilated
Cons
Non-Closable Vents
Not for Everyone
Weight: 360 grams
Adjustment System: Custom dial adjustment system
Number of Vents: 20
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Goggle Attachment: Yes
Visor: Yes (brim)
Audio Compatibility: No
POC Auric Cut Backcountry Spin
- Comfort 80%
- Warmth 90%
- Ventilation 90%
- Safety Tech & Features 90%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 40%
Pros
Cutting Edge Safety Tech
Warm
Well Ventilated
Cons
Heavy
Look is Not for Everyone
Weight: 585 grams
Adjustment System: 360-degree adjustment
Number of Vents: 10 adjustable
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Google Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: Yes
- Comfort 80%
- Warmth 80%
- Ventilation 90%
- Safety Tech & Features 70%
- Goggle Compatibility 80%
- Weight 60%
Pros
Price to Performance Ratio
Warm
Comfortable
Cons
Lacks Safety Features of Top of the Line Smith Helmets
Weight: 538.65 grams
Adjustment System: BOA Fit System
Number of Vents: 18
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Google Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: Yes
Smith Vantage MIPS
- Comfort 90%
- Warmth 90%
- Ventilation 90%
- Safety Tech & Features 90%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 60%
Pros
Most of the Features of the Quantum at a Lower Price
Cons
Lacks the Ultra-Premium Protection of the Quantum
Weight: 501.8 grams
Adjustment System: BOA FS360 Fit System
Number of Vents: 18
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Goggle Attachment: Yes
Visor: No
Audio Compatibility: Yes
Oakley Mod5 MIPS
- Comfort 80%
- Warmth 70%
- Ventilation 80%
- Safety Tech & Features 70%
- Goggle Compatibility 90%
- Weight 40%
Pros
Modular Brim System
BOARetention System
Comfortable
Cons
Cold Earpads
Average Ventilation
Poor Quality of Goggle Clip
Weight: 601 grams
Adjustment System: BOA 270 fit system
Number of Vents: 11 on MIPS helmet
Removable Ear Covers: Yes
Goggle Attachment: Yes
Visor: Yes
Audio Compatibility: No
Comfort and Fit
Like the ultra-premium Smith Quantum, the Smith Vantage MIPS is among the most comfortable ski and snowboard helmets on the market, and the fit of the two helmets is nearly identical, due to the use of the BOA FS360 Fit System. The BOA system really makes the helmet conform to the shape of your head when you cinch it down, rather than just feeling like a band is pinching tighter on the back of your head, which is the feeling that some retention systems give. Furthermore, it allows for a wide range of adjustability for riders who want to comfortably wear a buff or beanie under their helmets, and It is also very easy to operate one-handed.
As a rule, Smith helmets are quite comfortable in general and fit a fairly broad selection of head shapes, and this is particularly true of the Smith Quantum and Vantage thanks to the BOA system. However, they do favor skiers and riders with a round shaped head, as opposed to the more oval shaped fit of Giro helmets.
Warmth
Also like the Quantum, the Smith Vantage is an exceptionally warm helmet. There is little to no airflow that finds its way between your cheeks and the earpads, and the Vantage MIPS’s 18 vents seal off tight against the wind.
Ventilation
While the Smith Quantum MIPS was our top overall pick for best ski and snowboard helmet, there are a few areas where the slightly cheaper Smith Vantage actually outshines it, and ventilation is one of those. While its 18 vents are four few than the quantum, the half shell Koroyd liner of the Smith Vantage lets air through that the full Koroyd lining of the Quantum does not. Meanwhile, the Smith Vantage MIPS features the same dual adjustment system and the Quantum, allowing you to independently open and close the front and rear vents to perfectly dial in your climate control.
Safety Tech and Additional Features
While the Smith Vantage matches the more expensive Quantum in nearly every category, this is the one where it comes up short.
Rather than the full Koroyd protective lining of the Smith Quantum, the Vantage uses about 50% less Koroyd. This does achieve better airflow while knocking a few grams off of the helmet, and Smith claims that it is still Koroyd reinforced in the highest potential impact zones. However, we go in for safety, and would prefer the full Koroyd Lining of the Quantum.
The hybrid construction of the Smith Vantage also lacks the exoskeleton reinforcement around the sides and back of the helmet, found on the Smith Quantum. Like the reduced Koroyd, this knocks both grams and dollars off of the Smith Vantage, and it is up to you to decide what you are willing to trade for increased protection.
The Smith Vantage features a standard buckle and chinstrap, rather than the single piece adjustment and magnetic Fidlock buckle found on the Smith Quantum. Finally, like the Quantum, the Vantage’s earpads are compatible with audio inserts such as the Chips 2.0 by Outdoor Tech.
Goggle Compatibility
Long before the folks at Smith were making top of the line helmets, they were busy making top of the line eyewear. Not surprisingly, this leads Smith helmets to be some of the best on the market when it comes to eyewear integration, and the Smith Vantage MIPS is no exception to that rule. In addition to simply fitting goggles well, the Smith Vantage utilizes Smith’s AirEvac2 to funnel moisture away from your goggles, making sure that they stay fog free.
While the Smith Vantage provides excellent integration with most goggles, the best combination of fit and ventilation is achieved when using the Vantage with Smith’s own snow goggles.
Weight
As in the ventilation department, this is another area where the Smith Vantage outshines the Quantum. At 501g, the Smith Vantage is on the lighter end of ski and snowboard helmets with a premium load of features, if not on the lighter end of ski and snowboard helmets altogether.
The Bottom Line
At $260, the Smith Vantage is an expensive helmet by just about any way of reckoning. However, it is a great all-around ski and snowboard helmet that is packed with features. Riders who want to save a few dollars and prioritize ventilation above all might prefer it to our top pick, the Smith Quantum. However, we are willing to take the price, weight, and ventilation tradeoffs in exchange for the supreme protection offered by the Smith Quantum. Riders on a budget meanwhile, might be better served by the Smith Variance, which includes much of the Vantage’s safety, without some of the bells and whistles or the Giro Nine, which was our best value award winner for ski and snowboard helmets.
Compare Prices From Retailers Below
You help support Gear Hacker by purchasing from our retail partners.